Listen, the 90s were a magical time. We had Beanie Babies, Dunkaroos, and absolutely zero understanding of resale value. Little did we know that the things we covered in Cheeto dust and left under the couch would one day be worth actual money.
So grab a flashlight, a protein shake (we’re older now, we need support), and prepare to take a heroic expedition into your parents’ basement — because these 10 toys might still be down there… and they might just pay for your next vacation.
10: Polly Pocket (90s Originals)
-
These tiny clamshell playsets — super nostalgic if you grew up in the 90s.
-
Complete sets (with box and all tiny bits) from pre-1998 production are the most collectible.
-
Current rough value: about US $50–$1,000+, depending on condition and completeness.
-
If you find a complete one under a stack of board games, it might be more than just a happy memory.
9: Tamagotchi (First Generation)
-
The pocket-sized virtual pet that made your backpack beep every five minutes. If you kept the first-gen model — and especially if it's still in its original packaging — collectors are interested.
-
A sealed/rare-edition first-gen Tamagotchi can sell for US $200 – $500+.
-
Loose or used ones still fetch modest nostalgia-prices (some in the tens or low hundreds).
8: Furby (1998 Original)
-
That fuzzy, weird little talking “pet” from 1998 — if you ignored its 3AM earwiggles, it might still be worth something.
-
For vintage first-gen Furbies: common used ones tend to sell around US $80–$150 if in decent shape.
-
If it’s a rare color, special edition, or (best case) mint-in-box, you might see US $300–$400+, sometimes even higher depending on collector interest.
7: 1993–1990s Game Boy Color (Original / Limited Editions)
-
The portable gaming powerhouse many of us abused with Mario, Pokémon, and more.
-
Retro-gaming collectors are still on the hunt — original Game Boy Colors (especially limited or rarer colors, boxed or with manuals/games) tend to fetch hundreds of dollars, depending on condition.
-
If you find one with the box + a few classic games, it’s definitely worth checking online.
6: 1990s Action Figures & Vintage Sets (e.g. 1993 Power Rangers Megazord)
-
Old-school action figures are having a little renaissance among nostalgia collectors.
-
For instance, a 1993 Megazord set (or similar complete ’90s-era sets) can fetch roughly US $500–$700 — though prices vary widely based on completeness and condition.
-
Loose or incomplete sets are often less valuable — but if you kept the box and all the bits, this could be a fun find.
5: Rare / “Special” Beanie Babies (Original 1990s Editions)
-
Not all Beanie Babies are a gold mine — but the rare ones (especially early/first-run, rare-tag or error-tag editions) still grab attention from collectors.
-
The high end of the spectrum: rare and mint-condition ones may see US $1,000 – $25,000+, depending on rarity and provenance.
-
Regular/common ones? Probably not worth much — but hey, worst case you got a plush teddy bear.
4: Vintage Consoles / Game Systems / Toys of Nostalgia Value (Mixed 90s Retro)
This slot is more of a “grab-bag” — mix of consoles, toys, rare video games, early collectible sets.
-
Some toys and game systems from the 90s, though more common, still have collectible appeal — especially complete boxed sets or early editions of popular consoles/games.
-
Prices here vary a lot based on rarity — could be modest hundreds to a few hundred dollars depending on demand and condition.
3: Original 1990s Vintage Action Figures & 90s Toy Lines (Loose & Complete Sets)
-
Some of the smaller-scale action figures or lesser-known 90s toy lines still have fans — particularly if they’re complete or rare variants. Collectors love the nostalgia factor.
-
Values vary widely: maybe tens to hundreds of dollars depending on how rare, complete, and “boxed” they are.
2: Early ’90s / ’99 Pokémon Trading Cards (non-Charizard but Holo / Rare Base Set Cards)
-
While the spotlight usually goes to Charizard, even other first-edition or holo/rare Base Set cards from 1999 can fetch solid money — especially in good condition.
-
Common rare holos or holo cards: many fall into hundreds to a few thousand USD, especially if graded or well preserved.
-
Worth checking — because sometimes complete near-mint cards that you forgot you had could surprise you.
1: The Big One: Original First Edition Charizard (1999 Base Set, Holographic)
-
If there’s one item that truly earned the “holy grail of 90s toys/cards” status — it’s this. The 1999 Base Set 1st Edition holo Charizard is legendary.
-
Market values (2025):
-
Ungraded “Near Mint” 1st Edition: roughly US $3,000–$6,000
-
Graded PSA 9–10 version: tens to hundreds of thousands — PSA 10 often goes for US $350,000–$500,000+ depending on demand.
-
Even “Shadowless” or lower-grade variants — while less valuable — can still fetch significant money compared to a regular card.
-
-
If you dig through your childhood stash and find one of these in good shape — brace yourself.
🔎 TL;DR — Why Some ’90s Toys Are Worth Big Bucks
-
Condition matters. Mint, sealed, complete, boxed or professionally graded = $$$. Loose, damaged, or incomplete = nostalgia at best.
-
Rarity + demand. Toys from huge franchises (like Pokémon) or those with limited runs/variants tend to hold value.
-
Nostalgia is real. Millennials — and now younger collectors — love owning pieces of childhood.
So yes — that dusty old bin in your parents’ basement? Might actually be a treasure chest.
